Yes, the weather was awful in Chicago this weekend, so that was prime movie-watching time. However, I wasn’t jumping to see Hangover 2 or Kung Fu Panda 2, so I used the weekend to catch up on one move that’s ready to leave the theater so I had to jump on it. The reviews for this movie have been pretty awful but, I read the book so I went in with low expectations. That is not always a good sign.
Rating: PG-13
Release date: May 6, 2011
Everyday Adventures’ grade: B
Summary: Rachel (Ginnifer Goodwin) and Darcy (Kate Hudson) are life-long friends but Darcy is a self-centered, narcissistic b*tch and Rachel is the long-suffering and sacrificing one in the friendship. But Darcy doesn’t know she’s her fiance Dex’s (Colin Egglesfield) sloppy seconds. Snap, he’s in love with Rachel and the two face their long-burning feelings for each other. That can never end well.
My thoughts: There are two words to describe how I felt walking out of this movie: pleasantly surprised. Again, after reading dismal reviews, I was not sure I would even see this in theaters. But a co-worker talked up John Kraskinski’s hotness in it (as Darcy and Rachel’s platonic friend Ethan) so…that’s worth $9, if for nothing else.
And I won’t bore you with paragraphs of John’s hotness or why my uterus and ovaries woke up and said “yeah, he’ll do…nicely,” but he is just as adorable and hot in prepster gear as he was in the movie “It’s Complicated.” His character is more well-developed too, but not by much. But that’s okay because really, his character doesn’t come full circle until the second book, more on that later.
Separate from John, the main people in this movie are Dex, Rachel and Darcy in a torturous, longing stare love triangle, which seems like a no brainer. The “opposites attract” appeal of Dex and Darcy is quickly overshadowed by the total unlikeableness of Darcy (even with a token soft moment) and the obvious attraction between Dex and Rachel. Where that relationship goes is pretty predictable, even with road block plot points like “should Dex call off the wedding?” “Why can’t Rachel just tell him how she feels?” “Why can’t Rachel go after what she wants for once?” The drama and back-and-forth eats up a bit too much of the movie’s 112 minute run time, but compared to the book (a series by Emily Giffin,) it’s cut down A LOT on the whining from Rachel about her betrayal of her “best friend.”
The main issue not really addressed fully (or enough to really give girls something to relate to) is the lingering feeling from Rachel that someone as smoking “staring at the sun” hot as Dex would go for frumpy Rachel. This frumpiness is played up at any chance, but that is core issue. It’s one I’ve dealt with (and I’m sure others) so I wish that was explored more. Looking back, most of the movie is about people pining for each other within this incestuous group of friends but not saying anything.
To be fair, I haven’t read this book in a while so there may be things in the movie I don’t remember from the book, but the addition of a heart-to-heart with Ethan and Rachel was totally unnecessary and reinforced my “pining” comment above. Why filmmakers feel the need to add stuff like that in when it adds no plot value and just eats time, baffles me.
But the moment they did build to was Darcy discovering Rachel and Dex’s affair and the moments leading up to that moment are really intense and kind of uncomfortable. And then when it’s time to unleash her b*tchy, I hate you moment, Darcy kind of falls flat, in that her character is so shrewd and unlikeable that she just lets it go too easily. I expected more.
Something Borrowed is part of a series from Giffin that includes the sequel (told from Darcy’s POV) called Something Blue. That was my favorite of the two books (due to a deeper character arc and development) and not much for it is set up in this movie and that sequel isn’t locked up to be happening, just yet.
BUT, definitely stay after the movie through the credits. Why? Let’s just say, there is a secret scene that you should check out. I’m so glad Liz made us stay through the credits because I would have missed it!
Re-reading this review, I’ve been a bit harsh and nitpicky on a few things related to the movie, but again, I was really pleasantly surprised by it, and after thinking about it more, it’s growing on me too.
It’s not perfect, but if you read the book, chances are that you will enjoy it.
Verdict: Wait for DVD or Netflix, but definitely see it if you read the book (but you can still wait for DVD)
Have you read any of Giffin’s books?




